Is Housing Affordability in Madison, WI Getting Better?

Published by Integrity Homes | September 22, 2025

For years, Madison has been known for its booming job market, excellent schools, and exceptional quality of life. But along with those positives has come a significant challenge: the cost of housing. As we move through 2025, many potential buyers and renters are asking the same pressing question—is affordability in Madison finally getting better?

At Integrity Homes, we understand that finding an affordable path to homeownership is more important than ever for Madison families. Let's take a closer look at the current market conditions and explore how our community heroes can benefit from special savings opportunities.

Home Prices: Slowing Growth, But Still Challenging

The good news is that home price growth is no longer racing ahead at the double-digit pace we witnessed in previous years. According to recent market reports, the median sale price sits at $455,000, representing about 2.2% growth over the past year. The average sale price is $534,115, with properties averaging approximately $259 per square foot.

While this represents more moderate growth compared to previous years, these price points still create substantial barriers for first-time buyers looking to enter the market. This pricing puts homeownership out of reach for many working families, despite Madison's strong employment opportunities.

Inventory: Signs of Improvement

One encouraging development for buyers is the current inventory situation showing 2.21 months of supply with approximately 1,151 active listings countywide. While this represents a cooling from the extremely tight conditions of peak market periods, it still favors sellers in most price ranges.

The market dynamics show homes selling quickly at a median of 9 days on market, with a median of 12 days to pending status. With 564 closings representing a 13.8% decrease year-over-year, and new listings down about 7.1% to 632 properties, the market is showing signs of more balanced activity compared to the frenetic pace of recent years.

The Affordability Reality Check

Despite cooling price growth, affordability remains significantly strained across the Madison area. Housing experts estimate that a household income of approximately $120,000 is needed to afford the median-priced Madison home at $455,000. This requirement sits well above the median income for many local households.

The challenge is even more pronounced for renters aspiring to homeownership. The median renter income in Madison is approximately $46,000—far short of what's typically needed to comfortably qualify for a mortgage on most available homes.

What's Driving These Housing Challenges?

Several interconnected factors continue to keep housing costs elevated:

Elevated Mortgage Rates – Interest rates remain higher than recent historical norms, making monthly payments more expensive even when home prices stabilize.

Persistent Supply Shortages – Madison still lacks sufficient affordable and moderately-priced homes to meet ongoing demand from local families and newcomers.

Sustained Demand – Continued job growth, the presence of the University of Wisconsin, and steady migration to the area maintain consistent housing demand.

External Market Pressures – Out-of-state buyers with greater purchasing power sometimes drive prices above asking, creating additional competition for local buyers.

Is the Situation Actually Improving?

The honest answer: slightly, but the fundamental challenges remain.

Positive developments include:

• Home price growth has moderated significantly—no longer experiencing unsustainable increases
• Inventory levels are gradually improving, providing buyers with more options and negotiating power
• Statewide affordability indexes show marginal improvements in some categories

However, the core mathematical challenge persists. For the typical Madison household, achieving homeownership remains a significant financial stretch. While the affordability crisis is showing signs of easing, these improvements are occurring primarily at the margins.

How Integrity Homes Is Making a Difference

At Integrity Homes, we're committed to helping make homeownership more accessible for Madison families. We focus on building quality, energy-efficient homes that provide long-term value while working to keep costs as reasonable as possible in today's market.

What Could Drive Future Improvements?

To create meaningful progress on housing affordability, Madison will need several key developments:

Lower Mortgage Rates – Even a modest decrease in interest rates would immediately boost buyer purchasing power across all income levels.

Expanded Affordable Housing Supply – More builders focusing on starter homes, townhomes, and moderately-priced condominiums to serve local income levels.

Income Growth – Wage increases that help keep pace with housing costs, particularly in essential service sectors.

Progressive Local Initiatives – Continued expansion of programs like down payment assistance, zoning reforms that encourage diverse housing types, and community-led affordability projects.

Looking Ahead: Our Commitment to Madison

Madison's housing market has certainly moved away from the breakneck pace of previous years, providing some relief for prospective buyers. However, "more affordable" doesn't yet translate to "truly affordable" for most local families.

At Integrity Homes, we remain committed to being part of the solution. We continue to explore innovative building techniques, efficient home designs, and community partnerships that can help make quality homeownership more accessible.

Whether you're a first-time buyer, a growing family, or a community hero looking to establish roots in Madison, we're here to help you explore your options and find a path toward homeownership that works for your situation.

The Bottom Line