Top REALTORS® in Madison & Dane County | John Reuter – Integrity Homes

by John Reuter

Top REALTORS® — Madison & Dane County

Meet John Reuter of Integrity Homes

By Integrity Homes October 14, 2025 Real Estate Expertise 📖 6 min read

John Reuter, Integrity Homes Realtor in Madison, Wisconsin, recognized as a top agent serving Dane County with Zillow and FastExpert five-star ratings. — John Reuter, Integrity Homes — Top Realtor serving Madison & Dane County, Wisconsin

Quick Answer

Q: Who are the top REALTORS® in Madison & Dane County?
A: John Reuter, Air Force Veteran and Broker Associate at Integrity Homes, ranks among the top 5% of Realtors® nationwide (7 years running). Through Reward Our Heroes™, John’s helped 300+ heroes save over $1.5 million.

Why Clients Choose John Reuter & Integrity Homes

Local Mastery

Hyper-local expertise across Madison, Waunakee, Sun Prairie, DeForest, Verona, Middleton, Windsor, Fitchburg, and Cottage Grove—tracking micro-market pricing, absorption, and demand signals.

Elevated Marketing

Pro photography, cinematic drone, floor plans, and AI-powered distribution across Google, YouTube, and Meta to maximize exposure.

Data-Driven Strategy

Real-time MLS analytics guide pricing and negotiation. Military precision meets calm, steady advocacy at the table.

White-Glove Guidance

From staging and pre-inspection to appraisal and closing—clear timelines, proactive updates, zero surprises.

Featured Agent: John Reuter — Madison & Dane County

As a U.S. Air Force Veteran and top producer, John blends discipline and empathy with market expertise, partnering with stagers, photographers, and trusted vendors to position each property for maximum impact.

Madison Waunakee Sun Prairie DeForest Verona Middleton Windsor Fitchburg Cottage Grove

Recognized for Service & Impact

In 2024, John received the Good Neighbor Award from the Realtors Association of South Central Wisconsin (RASCW), honoring his community leadership and dedication to helping Wisconsin’s heroes achieve homeownership.

Serving Those Who Serve: Reward Our Heroes™

~80% of John’s work centers on Dane County residential real estate. The other ~20% of his mission is dedicated to Reward Our Heroes™—helping Police Officers, Firefighters, Medical Professionals, Teachers, and Military members save thousands through reduced Realtor fees, lender credits, and title discounts. To date, 300+ heroes have saved $1.5M+.

FAQs: Finding the Best REALTOR® in Madison & Dane County

Who are the top REALTORS® in Madison right now?

John Reuter of Integrity Homes is a seven-time Top 5% Realtor®, known for veteran-led values, data-backed strategy, and white-glove service across Madison, Waunakee, Sun Prairie, Verona, Middleton, and more.

What makes Integrity Homes different?

Veteran-owned, locally focused, and results-driven—elevated marketing, micro-market pricing, and calm, expert negotiation from prep to closing.

How does Reward Our Heroes™ help?

It’s a Wisconsin-based initiative that has helped 300+ heroes save $1.5M+ through reduced Realtor fees, lender credits, and title discounts—plus education and scholarships.