The median home price in Sun Prairie is $431,000 as of October 2025, representing a 1.4% increase year-over-year. The average sale price is $461,784, up 2.9% from last year. This sustained pricing strength demonstrates continued buyer demand despite lower sales volume.

Sun Prairie remains a strong seller's market with only 2.13 months of inventory. A balanced market typically has 5-6 months of supply. However, fall 2025 conditions are gradually balancing, giving buyers more negotiating leverage than earlier in the year. Well-priced homes under $500K still sell within 8-13 days on average.

Sun Prairie home prices are rising. The median price increased 1.4% year-over-year to $431,000, while the average price climbed 2.9% to $461,784. September alone saw a 10.1% year-over-year increase. Over the past decade, prices have surged 69% from $255,000 in 2017. Dane County economists project continued 4% annual appreciation through 2030.

Sun Prairie commands premium pricing compared to many area communities. The 53590 zip code shows 12.6% year-over-year appreciation to $438,000 median, outperforming neighboring areas significantly. This reflects Sun Prairie's top-rated schools, expanding infrastructure, Madison proximity, and community amenities.

There are 108 active listings in Sun Prairie as of October 2025. This represents just 2.13 months of inventory, well below the 5-6 months considered a balanced market. The limited inventory continues to support strong pricing and quick sales velocity.

Sun Prairie saw 477 year-to-date sales, down 13.1% from 2024. This reflects broader market normalization after several years of unusually high activity. Despite lower volume, prices continue rising (+1.4% YoY), demonstrating that demand remains solid.

Sun Prairie's A+ rated school district is a primary driver of home values. The district consistently ranks among Wisconsin's best. Neighborhoods within Cardinal Heights Upper Middle School and Sun Prairie High School boundaries command premium pricing, contributing to the 53590 zip code's 12.6% year-over-year appreciation.

The $300K-$500K price range dominates, accounting for 52% of all 2025 sales. The $400K-$499K segment alone represents 33% of sales. These homes sell fastest (8-13 days) and often at or above asking price.

The market remains competitive but is balancing. With 108 active listings and 2.13 months of supply, inventory is tight. However, the sale-to-list ratio is 99.03%, meaning most homes sell right at asking price. Fall 2025 offers more negotiating room than spring markets.

Fall 2025 presents a strategic buying window. With fewer competitors, you can negotiate seller credits and favorable terms unavailable during spring. Combined with potential future refinancing, buying now positions you well before spring 2026 competition returns.

The 53590 core zip code is most desirable, with median prices at $438,000 and 12.6% year-over-year appreciation. New construction areas near schools, established neighborhoods near downtown, and communities with easy Madison highway access command premium pricing.

Yes, fall 2025 offers negotiating opportunities. You can negotiate seller credits toward closing costs, home warranty coverage, repair credits, extended closings, and appliance inclusions. Homes above $600K offer more room than those under $500K.

Buyers typically pay 2-5% of purchase price in closing costs. On a $431,000 home, expect $8,620-$21,550 including loan fees, appraisal, inspection, title insurance, and prepaid taxes/insurance. Fall buyers often negotiate seller credits to offset costs.

Absolutely. Fall 2025's balanced conditions allow inspection contingencies. A $400-600 inspection can identify $10,000+ in issues. You can often negotiate repair credits or price reductions, especially on homes above $500K.

Average days on market is just 8 days year-to-date. September's median was 14 days. Homes priced $300K-$500K sell within 8-13 days. Properties above $600K average 10-15 days. Accurate pricing and professional presentation ensure quick sales.

Fall 2025 remains favorable for sellers. Limited inventory (2.13 months) keeps leverage in sellers' hands. Homes under $500K sell in under two weeks. Winter buyers tend to be more serious and motivated, resulting in cleaner transactions.

Current sale-to-list ratio is 99.03%. In the $300K-$399K range, homes average 0.2% over asking; $400K-$499K sees 0.3% over. Higher-priced homes above $500K typically sell 0.5-0.6% below asking.

Focus on move-in ready condition: fresh neutral paint, updated kitchen hardware, modern lighting, professional landscaping, deep cleaning, and minor repairs. Professional staging significantly impacts sale speed and price.

Sun Prairie shows strong investment fundamentals. The market delivered 69% appreciation over eight years. Economists project 4% annual appreciation through 2030, potentially adding 25% to current values. The 53590 core is particularly strong with 12.6% year-over-year gains.

Sun Prairie expanded from 29,364 in 2010 to over 35,000 in 2025—a 20% population growth. Limited land supply combined with sustained growth supports the 69% price appreciation since 2017. Infrastructure expansion and school growth continue attracting families.