Client Reviews for John Reuter - Integrity Homes
Real stories from buyers, sellers, and local heroes we’ve helped across Waunakee, Madison, Sun Prairie, and Dane County. Browse featured highlights below, then scroll for all reviews.
Last updated: December 2025
Featured Reviews
★★★★★
We were specifically looking for a Realtor in Madison who helps veterans, and that’s how we found John Reuter with Integrity Homes. From the very beginning, he made the process clear, smooth, and stress-free.
Ryan Fischer • Google Review
★★★★★
We relocated to Wisconsin for a job transfer and wanted a Realtor who aligned with Dave Ramsey’s principles. John was the perfect fit and made our move incredibly smooth.
Cody McDuffy • Google Review
★★★★★
We bought our new home and sold our last one in less than 24 hours. Even years later, we still can’t get over how easy it was working with the Reuter Team through Reward Our Heroes.
Elle Kreyer Moxon • Facebook Recommendation
★★★★★
John Reuter and the team at Integrity Homes are outstanding. Professional, knowledgeable, and always looking out for your best interests throughout the entire process.
Steven Rose • Google Review
★★★★★
As a nurse with a hectic schedule, I truly appreciated how organized and responsive John was. He helped us successfully buy and sell while keeping everything on track.
Kristin Balliette • Google Review
★★★★★
As a mortgage lender, I’ve worked with John on many transactions. His expertise in the VA loan process is exceptional, and his clients are always well-prepared.
Tony Burns • Google Review
Buyer Experiences
★★★★★
First-time home buyers here thanks to John and his team. He was patient, knowledgeable, and helped us every step of the way.
Kristina Vang • Google Review
★★★★★
John took care of me like I was his own. He was extremely responsive and flexible, and I’d recommend him to anyone looking for a home.
Sam Doying • Google Review
★★★★★
We bought our first house and the entire process from start to finish was very easy. I wouldn’t have wanted to work with anyone else.
Jacquelyn Willman • Facebook Recommendation
★★★★★
John helped my daughter purchase her home during COVID. He was incredibly helpful and knowledgeable, and we truly appreciated his guidance.
AO • Google Review
Seller Experiences
★★★★★
Our home was listed on a Friday afternoon, and by Monday we were signing an accepted offer. John made the process seamless.
Jocelynn Lindstrand • Google Review
★★★★★
John and his team guided me through selling my family home with ease during a difficult time. That peace of mind meant everything.
Sara • Google Review
★★★★★
John handled the sale of our duplex efficiently and carefully. The entire process was smooth and stress-free.
Donna D. • Google Review
★★★★★
Selling our home was a challenging situation, but John navigated it professionally and kept everything moving forward.
Madalyn Rowley • Google Review
Veterans & Heroes
★★★★★
We specifically wanted a Realtor who helps veterans, and John delivered exactly that with professionalism and care.
Ryan Fischer • Google Review
★★★★★
Before my PCS to Madison, multiple unit members recommended John. His experience with military moves made all the difference.
Michael Swartz • Google Review
★★★★★
An outstanding experience, especially for those in the veteran community. John understands the process and advocates for his clients.
Thomas Parr • Google Review
★★★★★
The money we saved through Reward Our Heroes was tremendous. John worked every possible angle to help us find the right home.
Alec Smith • Facebook Recommendation
Verified Google Reviews
Real experiences from buyers, sellers, and local heroes across Dane County, Wisconsin
ricky parmar
Had a great interaction with John today
Briana Buhrman
We weren’t actively searching at first, but we were open to finding the right home. After missing out on one house, we ended up finding the perfect one, and John helped us move quickly to make everything happen.
At the same time, we had to get our Sun Prairie home ready to sell. John gave us great advice on what to do to prepare and stage the home, and helped us get everything ready for a quick sale. His marketing went beyond just putting the home on the market. He even walked the neighborhood and invited neighbors to a special open house.
In the end, our home sold over asking, and John helped us through both the sale of our home and the purchase of our next one. When a major issue came up on closing day that was completely out of our control, John stayed calm, communicated clearly, and helped keep everything moving. We had already packed up and were ready to move, so it was an incredibly stressful situation, but John helped navigate it and got us to closing.
John truly went above and beyond for us. We are very grateful for everything he did and have already referred him to someone else. We would highly recommend John to anyone buying or selling a home.
Nicole B
We first met John Reuter with Integrity Homes a couple of years before we actually bought our home in Sun Prairie. Even though it took us some time to find the perfect home, John always stayed in touch. He never pressured us and was always available to answer any questions we had along the way.
When we finally had an offer accepted on the home we loved, the appraisal required a few repairs before the loan could move forward. John didn’t hesitate—he actually went to the home himself and completed the repairs to make sure everything would meet the loan requirements and keep the process moving.
That level of dedication meant a lot to us and showed how much he truly cares about his clients. If you’re looking for a Realtor who goes above and beyond, we would absolutely recommend John Reuter and Integrity Homes when buying a home in Sun Prairie.