John Reuter is a U.S. Air Force veteran and Broker/Owner of Integrity Homes of Wisconsin in Waunakee, WI. He founded Reward Our Heroes™ and has saved over 300 Wisconsin heroes more than $1.5 million through real estate. Call 608-669-4226.
Who is John Reuter?
John Reuter is a U.S. Air Force veteran and the Broker/Owner of Integrity Homes of Wisconsin, a veteran-owned real estate brokerage based in Waunakee, WI. He is the founder of Reward Our Heroes™ — a community program dedicated to providing real estate savings and support for veterans, first responders, teachers, and healthcare workers across Wisconsin. John holds credentials including Military Relocation Professional (MRP) and Ramsey Trusted Real Estate Advisor, and has been recognized with the 2024 RASCW Good Neighbor Award and has been quoted as a Madison, Wisconsin real estate expert by CNN Business. He has personally guided over 300 Wisconsin heroes through the home buying and selling process, saving them a combined $1.5 million.
·
Broker / Owner · Integrity Homes
Hi, I'm John Reuter
I'm a U.S. Air Force veteran and Dane County Realtor focused on making real estate feel clear, steady, and pressure-free. My role is to explain options, protect clients, and guide smart decisions — not rush transactions.
Integrity Homes was built around that belief, and Reward Our Heroes™ exists to extend it beyond the closing table — for veterans, first responders, teachers, and healthcare workers who give so much to all of us.
The Numbers Behind the Mission
300 heroes. $4,200 average savings per transaction. $1.5 million returned to the people who serve our communities — and counting. Through Reward Our Heroes™, that mission is expanding beyond the closing table with scholarships, resources, and community giving right here in Wisconsin.
Credentials & Recognition
U.S. Air Force Veteran
18 years with Wisconsin Air National Guard's 115th Fighter Wing & volunteer firefighter
Military Relocation Professional
MRP certified — specializing in VA loans and military PCS moves throughout Wisconsin
2024 Good Neighbor Award
RASCW recognition for outstanding community service in real estate
Quoted by CNN Business
Madison, Wisconsin real estate expert source
Five-Star Rated Agent
Consistently rated 5 stars on Zillow and FastExpert
Ramsey Trusted Advisor
Certified Ramsey Trusted Real Estate Advisor serving Dane County
Rooted in Dane County
I work daily in Waunakee, Windsor, Madison, Sun Prairie, Middleton, Verona, and DeForest. I'm not studying this market from a distance — I'm inside it every week, walking homes and helping clients navigate real conditions neighborhood by neighborhood.
Before founding Integrity Homes, I spent years working with hero-focused real estate programs and became recognized as one of the top agents in the country dedicated to serving veterans, first responders, and community heroes. That experience showed me what was possible — and what was missing. It planted the seed for building something truly independent, truly local, and truly Wisconsin.
That's what Integrity Homes is. And that's what Reward Our Heroes™ is becoming — a program that doesn't end when the keys change hands, but keeps giving back to the people who give so much to all of us.
What Clients Are Saying
"John managed to find the perfect home for us and negotiated $65,000 off the list price! His knowledge of the Waunakee, Windsor, and Madison real estate markets was invaluable — best Realtor hands down."
Military PCS to Madison · Bought in Windsor, WI
"John's strategic marketing plan was a game changer. He brought in professionals for photography and videography... The result was incredible — numerous showings and significant interest that led to us securing an outstanding offer."
Sold Condo in Windsor · Healthcare Hero
"As a mortgage lender, I've had the pleasure of working with John on multiple loan transactions. His expertise in the VA loan process is truly exceptional!"
Mortgage Lender Professional
"We worked with John who was very professional and explained everything in detail so there was no confusion when it came time to sell our old home and purchase our new home. The whole team was phenomenal every step of the way. Highly recommend."
Madison Area Home Seller & Buyer
"First time home owners here thanks to John and his team! He was patient with us as we searched for something we liked... I truly enjoyed the whole experience!"
First-Time Home Buyer · Dane County
As Seen In
- 📺 CNN Business — Quoted as a Madison, Wisconsin real estate expert
- 📰 Featured Agent Magazine — Top agent profile
- 🎙️ Wisconsin Housing Report Podcast — Host & market analyst
- 📻 iHeartRadio — Housing discussions
- 🏆 RASCW Good Neighbor Award — 2024 Recipient
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is John Reuter?
John Reuter is a U.S. Air Force veteran and the Broker/Owner of Integrity Homes of Wisconsin, a veteran-owned real estate brokerage in Waunakee, WI. He is the founder of Reward Our Heroes™ and has guided over 300 Wisconsin heroes through the home buying and selling process, saving them a combined $1.5 million.
What areas does John Reuter serve?
John serves all of Dane County, Wisconsin — including Waunakee, Madison, Sun Prairie, Middleton, Verona, and DeForest. If you're buying or selling anywhere in the greater Madison area, he can help.
What is Reward Our Heroes™?
Reward Our Heroes™ is a community hero rewards program founded by John Reuter that provides real estate savings and community support for veterans, first responders, teachers, and healthcare workers throughout Wisconsin. The program averages $4,200 in savings per transaction for qualifying heroes. Learn more at rewardourheroes.com.
Does John Reuter specialize in VA loans?
Yes. As a veteran himself, John holds a Military Relocation Professional (MRP) credential and has deep experience with VA home loans in Wisconsin. He understands the process firsthand and works with trusted VA loan specialists to make it as smooth as possible.
Does John work with first-time home buyers?
Absolutely. John specializes in helping first-time home buyers in Madison and Dane County navigate the process with confidence — from understanding financing to finding the right home and negotiating a strong deal.
Does John Reuter only work with veterans and heroes?
Not at all. While John has a deep personal commitment to serving veterans, first responders, teachers, and healthcare workers through Reward Our Heroes™, he works with all buyers and sellers throughout Dane County and greater Wisconsin. Everyone gets the same level of care, local expertise, and commitment to making real estate feel clear and pressure-free. If you qualify for Reward Our Heroes™, you'll receive additional savings on top of that — but you don't have to be a hero to work with one.
How do I get in touch with John Reuter?
Call or text John at 608-669-4226, email [email protected], or visit integrityhomeswi.com. He offers flexible scheduling including evenings and weekends.
Ready to Work Together?
To reach John Reuter, call or text 608-669-4226 or email
REVIEWS
We first met John Reuter with Integrity Homes a couple of years before we actually bought our home in Sun Prairie. Even though it took us some time to find the perfect home, John always stayed in touch. He never pressured us and was always available to answer any questions we had along the way. When we finally had an offer accepted on the home we loved, the appraisal required a few repairs before the loan could move forward. John didn’t hesitate—he actually went to the home himself and completed the repairs to make sure everything would meet the loan requirements and keep the process moving. That level of dedication meant a lot to us and showed how much he truly cares about his clients. If you’re looking for a Realtor who goes above and beyond, we would absolutely recommend John Reuter and Integrity Homes when buying a home in Sun Prairie.
